Donations to the Community of Sant'Egidio are tax deductible
under current regulations

Also this year it can target the 5x1000 to the Community of Sant'Egidio
Write the number 80191770587 in the tax return

Andrea Riccardi: on the web

Andrea Riccardi: on social networks

Andrea Riccardi: press review

change language
you are in: no death penalty - news contacting usnewsletterlink

Support The Community

 
January 22 2009 | UGANDA

Uganda

Supreme Court retains death penalty. Executions within 3 years, or sentences automatically commuted to life prison

 
printable version

ANSA

PENA MORTE: UGANDA LA CONFERMA, MA NON L'APPLICHERA'

NAIROBI, 21 GEN - La Corte Suprema ugandese ha oggi confermato la costituzionalita' della pena di morte, con alcune precisazioni che pero' fanno intendere che essa non sara' piu' applicata, e che di fatto tutte le condanne saranno tramutate in ergastolo. Lo rende noto la Bbc on line.

Il giudizio rovescia il parere espresso nel 2005 da un tribunale ordinario, che aveva deciso l'abolizione della pena capitale su istanza di 400 condannati a morte.

La Suprema Corte ha sentenziato che tale normativa deve continuare ad esistere per la sua funzione ''deterrente'', ma ha anche sancito che i condannati non possano restare nel braccio della morte in attesa dell'esecuzione per piu' di tre anni. Dati i tempi della giustizia, significa che a tutti automaticamente la pena sara' commutata in carcere a vita.

La Corte ha anche chiesto che il Parlamento cambi il metodo attualmente previsto per le esecuzioni, abolendo l'impiccagione, ritenuta ''crudele, inumana e degradante''. In Uganda, comunque, malgrado le numerose condanne, non ci sono state impiccagioni dal 1999.

 

The New Vision

Uganda: Supreme Court Retains Death Penalty

Anne Mugisa and Hillary Nsambu

21 January 2009

Kampala — The Supreme Court has refused to outlaw the death penalty. However, the court said once the death sentence is confirmed, the condemned person should either be executed within three years or his sentence commuted to life.

The court ruled that the death sentence was not inconsistent with the Constitution of Uganda.

It confirmed the 2005 Constitutional Court ruling that the death sentence should not be mandatory but discretionary.

The coram comprised of Chief Justice Benjamin Odoki and justices J.W. Tsekooko, Joseph Mulenga, George Kanyeihamba, Bart Katureebe, Christine Kitumba and Egonda Ntende.

Citing one of the capital offences, the judges ruled that not all murders are committed in the same circumstances and that not all murderers are of the same character.

"One may be a first offender, and the murder may have been committed in circumstances that the accused person deeply regrets and is very remorseful. We see no reason why these factors should not be put before the court before it passes the ultimate sentence," they ruled.

"We, therefore, agree with the Constitutional Court that those laws on the Statute book in Uganda which provide for a mandatory death sentence are inconsistent with the Constitution and, therefore, are void to the extent of that inconsistency," it ruled.

The State appealed to the Supreme Court in 2006 following the Constitutional Court ruling that made the death sentence not mandatory and the delay in execution beyond three years unlawful.

The ruling came after 418 prisoners on death row, led by Susan Kigula, petitioned against the death sentence as unconstitutional. Kigula, who was sentenced to death for murdering her husband, was in the courtroom when the ruling was being passed. As soon as the court upheld the death penalty, Kigula started sobbing.

Chris Rwakasisi, who was released from death row on the presidential prerogative of mercy only the day before, was also in the courtroom.

On the delay in the execution of the death sentence, the court ruled that the sentence should not be carried out in a hurry. The judges said the condemned person should be allowed time to exhaust the appeal processes and the executive pardon.

In the meantime, the condemned should not be held in demeaning conditions.

They said the condemned person should not be indefinitely kept on death row. "This in effect makes them serve a long period of imprisonment to which they were not sentenced in the first place. Evidence was given of persons who have spent as long as 18 years on death row without decisions by the Executive as to their fate," the judges noted.

"As soon as the highest court has confirmed sentence, the Advisory Committee on the Prerogative of Mercy and the Prisons authorities should commence to process the applications so that the President is advised without unreasonable delay.

"At the end of a period of three years after the highest appellate court confirmed the sentence, and if the President shall not have exercised his prerogative one way or the other, the death sentence shall be deemed commuted to life imprisonment without remission," the judges stated.

The court also ruled that the petitioners who hinged their appeal on the death sentence being mandatory and had cases awaiting ruling in an appeal court, their cases should be sent to the High Court to be heard only on mitigation of sentence.

By a majority of six to one, the court also ruled that no sufficient evidence was brought to show that being hanged caused more pain and suffering to the person being executed than any other manner of execution.

The dissenting judge, Egonda Ntende, said there was evidence that death does not occur instantly when a person is hanged.

He said the person's wrists and ankles are tied before execution, which restrains him from reacting to pain, distress or suffocation.

"The person hanged often sweats, drools, the eyes bulge and he urinates and defecates," the judge explained before stressing that the exercise was, therefore, dehumanising and should stop.

 

AFP

L'Ouganda restreint l'application de la peine de mort

KAMPALA, 21 jan 2009  - La Cour suprême ougandaise a ordonné mercredi que les condamnations à mort soient commuées en peines de prison à vie pour les condamnés ayant passé plus de trois ans dans le couloir de la mort.

Dans son arrêt consulté par l'AFP, la Cour suprême reconnaît le caractère constitutionnel de la peine de mort mais statue qu'un "délai de trois ans (de prison) au-delà de la condamnation à mort est un délai excessif".

Cette décision fait suite à une procédure engagée par une importante association ougandaise de défense des droits de l'Homme au nom de 413 condamnés à mort.

"C'est une avancée très importante car nombre de gens qui attendent dans le couloir de la mort s'y trouvent depuis plus de trois ans", s'est félicité Livingstone Sewanyana, le président de la Fondation pour l'initiative en faveur des droits de l'Homme.

Selon M. Sewanyana, environ 330 de ses clients tombent sous le coup de cette nouvelle mesure.

L'avocat Frederic Sempebwa, qui a défendu ce dossier pour les condamnés, s'est dit peu surpris de la confirmation, par la Cour, du caractère constitutionnel de la peine de mort.

"Nous n'étions pas très optimistes sur la possibilité de voir la peine de mort complètement supprimée, compte tenu de l'opinion générale dans le pays", a-t-il déclaré à l'AFP.

"Des (crimes comme les) sacrifices d'enfants ont toujours cours dans le pays. Cela joue sur l'opinion publique et sur la Cour", a-t-il ajouté.

La Cour suprême a cependant encouragé dans son arrêt le Parlement "à rouvrir le débat sur le caractère souhaitable ou non de la peine de mort dans notre Constitution".

La juridiction rappelle que la peine capitale n'a plus été appliquée en Ouganda depuis 1999 "ce qui semble témoigner d'un désir de se départir de la peine de mort".

"Nous avons fait un long chemin. En 1993, c'était encore un sujet tabou. Il n'était pas envisageable ne serait-ce que de discuter de la suppression de la peine de mort", a souligné M. Sewanyana.

Le Burundi et le Rwanda voisins ont tous deux aboli la peine de mort respectivement en 2008 et 2007.

 

RELATED NEWS
November 29 2016
BELARUS

Death convict Ivan Kulesh executed

November 29 2016

On November 30th join the World Day of the Cities for Life against the death penalty


How, when and where to join all over the world. The map of the cities, latest news, video. Visit this page for updates and share it! The hashtag is #nodeathpenalty
November 29 2016
UNITED STATES
Join the lay Catholic Community of Sant'Egidio

Various locations throughout the Florida dioceses will again participate in the International Day of Cities for Life


You are invited to attend an event in your area! Cities for Life, Against the Death Penalty
November 21 2016
NEW YORK, UNITED STATES
The results at the Third Committee of the General Assembly, the committee regarding issues relating to human rights, show momentum against the death penalty in the world

Death Penalty: the yes vote increases at the Third UN Committee, reaching a total of 115


Its resolution is debated and voted every other year
November 8 2016
KENYA

Death penalty: Sant'Egidio in Nairobi. From commuting sentences to humanizing society

November 5 2016
ZIMBABWE

10 death row inmates freed

all related news

ASSOCIATED PRESS
November 28 2016
AP

High court to examine mental disability, death penalty issue
November 12 2016
Internazionale

Si rafforza la pena di morte negli Stati Uniti
November 11 2016

Al liceo classico “Socrate” di Bari, conferenza “Non c’è giustizia senza vita”
October 24 2016
New York Times

The Death Penalty, Nearing Its End
June 4 2016
The Washington Post

Meet the red-state conservatives fighting to abolish the death penalty
all press-related

VIDEO PHOTOS
4:04
Motion Grafic "cities for life" 2012 -
4:14
Motion Grafic cities for life FR -
3:01
Promo Engl 2013 citiesforlife -

72 visits

232 visits

49 visits

53 visits

61 visits
all the related media