Donations to the Community of Sant'Egidio are tax deductible
under current regulations

Also this year it can target the 5x1000 to the Community of Sant'Egidio
Write the number 80191770587 in the tax return

Andrea Riccardi: on the web

Andrea Riccardi: on social networks

Andrea Riccardi: press review

change language
you are in: no death penalty - news newslettercontact uslink

Support The Community

 
January 12 2010 | UNITED STATES

USA

Lawyers challenge Ohio on Romell Broom's case

 
printable version

The New York Times

Lawyers Challenge Ohio on Executions

By IAN URBINA

January 12, 2010

Proper training of prison officials could have prevented a botched execution in Ohio last year that led the state to overhaul its method of execution, lawyers for several death row inmates have argued in court filings.

The filings contend that Ohio prison officials have shown a consistent disregard for their own rules in carrying out executions, including failing to ensure that execution staff members attend required rehearsals and training.

And they contend that one of the people who helped conduct the botched execution on Sept. 15, involving an inmate named Romell Broom, was inadequately trained and had failed to attend all the required rehearsals.

That employee is a licensed emergency medical technician, but has not worked as one for several years, does not regularly establish IVs and was out of practice at the time of Mr. Broom’s attempted execution, according to the court documents filed Friday in Federal District Court in Columbus.

Mr. Broom, 53, was convicted of kidnapping, raping and killing Tryna Middleton, 14, in 1984. At his scheduled execution, prison officials stuck him repeatedly with a needle for nearly two hours in a failed effort to find a usable vein. Gov. Ted Strickland ordered the execution halted.

“Were prison staff appropriately trained and if prison officials followed protocol, they might have avoided the sort of cruel and unconstitutional treatment that Mr. Broom faced,” said Adele Shank, one of Mr. Broom’s lawyers, adding that she intended to try to prevent the state from going forward with her client’s execution.

“The state got their chance with Mr. Broom,” Ms. Shank said. “They failed to execute him, and, in the process, they violated his constitutional right to avoid cruel and unusual punishment. So we are arguing it would be further cruelty for them to try again.”

State prison officials declined to comment because of the pending litigation. But they have said they believe the state’s new protocols are effective and not painful.

Lawyers for other death row inmates said they hoped to stop all executions in Ohio until the state’s execution protocols were brought up to constitutional standards and there were better guarantees that those protocols would be followed.

In a 2008 ruling that upheld the three-drug cocktail Kentucky used in executions, the Supreme Court rejected the claim that it posed an unconstitutional risk of a condemned inmate’s suffering acute yet undetectable pain.

But Allen L. Bohnert, a death row lawyer in Ohio, said the decision by the Supreme Court that the three-drug cocktail was constitutional was based on the faulty assumption that states followed protocol, when in Ohio, he said, that was proving not to be true.

In the attempted execution of Mr. Broom and in the June execution of Daniel Wilson, state prison officials ignored the requirement that they conduct three reviews of the inmates’ veins shortly before the execution to ensure that they had accessible veins, Mr. Bohnert said.

In the execution of Marvallous Keene last summer, prison officials ignored the requirement to establish two functional IV sites before starting the execution, the filings said.

On the day of Mr. Broom’s scheduled execution, state officials asked a doctor to help find a usable vein, even though that doctor had not received any of the training required to participate in an execution, the filings said.

In November, Ohio became the first state to say it would switch to a single drug, rather than a three-drug cocktail, in its death penalty procedure.

Critics have long argued that using a single drug, the preferred method in animal euthanasia, is more humane than the three-drug cocktail, which involves a short-acting barbiturate to render the inmate unconscious, followed by a paralytic and then a chemical to stop the heart.

RELATED NEWS
June 26 2018
MANILA, PHILIPPINES
Mr. Rodolfo Diamante, executive secretary of the bishops’ Commission on Prison Pastoral Care, presents

The Catholic Bishops' Conference of the Philippines agency remains vigilant against death penalty


A handbook against death penalty after a Mass commemorating the 12th anniversary of the abolition of the capital punishment in the country
May 3 2018
UNITED STATES

Board grants stay of execution for condemned Georgia inmateBY KATE BRUMBACKAssociated Press


We continue to send appeals and to pray for Robert Butts, only 90 days
April 10 2018
CÔTE D'IVOIRE

Final declaration of the African Congress


By the participants in the African Regional Congress, organised in Abidjan (Ivory Coast) from 09 to 10 April, 2018
April 9 2018
3rd Regional Congress Against the Death Penalty

The Regional Congress of the abolitionist associations in Abidjan, Ivory Coast, on 9-10 April 2018


Over 300 participants are expected
February 23 2018
UNITED STATES

Minutes before execution, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott commutes the sentence of Thomas Whitaker!


Gov. Greg Abbott spared the life of a death row inmate less than an hour before his scheduled execution
February 23 2018
UNITED STATES

The state of Florida carried out the execution of Branch on Thursday evening at the Florida State Prison in Raiford


Branch, who was on death row for nearly 25 years, was pronounced dead of a lethal injection at 6:05 p.m. Central Standard Time
all related news

ASSOCIATED PRESS
November 28 2016
AP

High court to examine mental disability, death penalty issue
November 12 2016
Internazionale

Si rafforza la pena di morte negli Stati Uniti
November 11 2016

Al liceo classico “Socrate” di Bari, conferenza “Non c’è giustizia senza vita”
October 24 2016
New York Times

The Death Penalty, Nearing Its End
June 4 2016
The Washington Post

Meet the red-state conservatives fighting to abolish the death penalty
all press-related

VIDEO PHOTOS
53
Video promo Cities for Life 2015
3:22

90 visits

244 visits

58 visits

67 visits

74 visits
all the related media